Showing posts with label Food Security. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Food Security. Show all posts

Thursday, April 24, 2014

ETHIOPIA: Pastoral elders give firsthand accounts of their suffering

FENTALLE, 2 May 2006 (IRIN) - 
Under the shade of acacia trees, 100 elders from pastoral communities in Ethiopia asked United Nations Special Humanitarian Envoy Kjell Magne Bondevik to help find lasting solutions to cope with the prevailing regional drought and preserve their way of life.

The traditional meeting, which was held at the Kereyu Gada village, some 190 km south of the capital, Addis Ababa, was part of the envoy's five-nation mission to the drought-plagued countries of the Horn of Africa. "My mission is to listen to your problems and to try to find lasting solutions," said Bondevik, who, like the elders, wore traditional white robes and sat on animal hides. "I promise that I will not forget you."

The meeting brought together pastoralists from the Kereyu, Somali, Gabra and Borana communities - some of whom had walked for three days to attend the gathering - and representatives of UN agencies. "This recent drought has been very severe. It has been nearly a year now without any proper rain. We have lost a lot of livestock," said Abdi Adar Ahmed, a prominent Somali elder from the eastern Ogaden Region.

According to UN figures, 12 million pastoralists in the Horn of Africa are suffering from drought. Bondevik and the UN delegation are visiting the region to hear firsthand accounts of the crisis and advocate for improved humanitarian assistance and long-term development.

"For us, pastoralism is work," said Gada Boku, chief administrator of the Kereyu clan, which hosted the meeting. "We live from our cattle, so we are very happy if people like you come to listen to us."

Some of the pastoralists from four different clans at the meeting with Bondevik
Like eight million other livestock keepers in Ethiopia, most pastoralists in Fentalle District have lost large numbers of cattle - the primary source of their income and sustenance - over the past months. Currently, 1.7 million people in Ethiopia are receiving food aid because of the drought.

"The response from the international community is not as it was in past years. They have to know that when our animals die, we die, as our lives are tied to them," said Kereyu Council Chief Gada Boku, whose white beard had been dyed with henna.

In the worst-hit areas, there has been little rain for the past five years. Nearly 60 percent of the cattle have died over the last two months, mainly from lack of water. Herders often have to walk up to 100km to find the precious resource. Livestock has lost 60 percent of its value, creating precarious circumstances for pastoral communities, which rely on sheep, goats and camels for food and income. Food prices have increased by as much as 50 percent, UN agencies said.

"I have lost around 10 cows and two camels. We had two boreholes - one has collapsed; the other one has dried up. And now my family has been put on food-aid rations," said Ibrahim Adano, a spiritual leader of the Gabra community in the southern Borana Region of Ethiopia.

During the two-hour meeting, the elders shared with the visiting delegation the challenges confronting their way of life, such as recurrent drought, lack of recognition, conflict and restrained trading opportunities. "Drought is not a sudden occurrence - it is a slow, upcoming phenomenon," said Somali elder Abdi Adar Ahmed. "We have to put in place a system so our animals can be sold before the drought, and the economy doesn't collapse. What we would like to have is recognition of pastoralism as viable work."

An elder addresses the meeting.
"Pastoralism needs to be recognised as a way of life that contributes to the economy. We need access to an organised market so we can be sustainable," said Nura Dida, a Borena elder. "We hope this meeting will become a milestone in pastoralist development."

The Horn of Africa, where more than 40 percent of the population is undernourished, is one of the most food-insecure regions in the world. The highly charged political environment caused by past and ongoing conflicts has made its people even more vulnerable, according to the UN.

Bondevik, who was made an elder of the Kereyu Gada clan during the special gathering, assured the pastoralists he would advocate on their behalf. "There is no doubt that there will be more droughts in the future, so we need to help pastoralists in the longer term," he said. "There are 12 million pastoralists [in the Horn]. We have to respect their way of life and improve their conditions, not try to change them, as this will cause much bigger problems. This is a tradition that has survived thousands of years."

The envoy reiterated the need for donors to continue their support to Ethiopia. "The situation is serious - there is no doubt that there is a crisis. [...] Ethiopia launched its own humanitarian appeal in January, requesting US$166 million. To date, $59.6 million [36 percent] has been received from the international community, which is a very positive response from the donor community, but more funds are still needed," he said.

The elders hoped Bondevik's visit would highlight the need for measures to preserve and improve the livelihoods of pastoral communities in Ethiopia. "The Iranian pastoralists have mobile schools, mobile hospitals, mobile phones and machines to pasteurise the milk and immediately export it. That's what we need. If Mr Bondevik could convey this message to the United Nations, it would be great," said Abdi Adar Ahmed.
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Defying orders to surrender illegal guns

MARSABIT, 22 March 2007 (IRIN) - 
The severe drought in northern Kenya last year and cattle rustling have wiped out more than half of Halake Wario's livestock, but failed to dampen his determination to remain a pastoralist. 

"Livestock keeping is part of my Borana tradition but it is risky and tough," Wario told IRIN in Marsabit district. "Many people have been killed in the past and livestock stolen, [leaving] many families poor, but I wish the same lifestyle for my children." 

Most of the deaths occurred when raiders from cattle-rustling communities in neighbouring Garissa District came to steal livestock from Wario's community in Marsabit. Many of his fellow Boranas died trying to defend their livestock from the raiders. 

After losing more than 100 head of cattle and a similar number of sheep and goats to raiders, Wario decided the best option was to acquire a gun. 

"We found a solution and managed to prevent frequent attacks from our Garissa neighbours after acquiring guns," he told IRIN. "Deployment of police officers after the attacks was not the solution … now we live in peace." 

Conditions in northern Kenya are harsh, with drought a common feature of the semi-arid region. Conflicts between the pastoralists and with communities from neighbouring Ethiopia are also common. In 2005, more than 70 people were killed when raiders suspected to be from Ethiopia attacked villages on the Kenyan side of the border. 

According to observers, conflicts are rampant in the region, partly because of local traditions as well as the large number of illegal guns. But like Wario, many residents of Marsabit insist they need the weapons to protect their lives and livestock. 

The view is shared by civil rights groups, development agencies and local leaders, who argue that the government’s failure to provide security forced the residents to acquire guns. 

Orders defied 

The pastoralists in the region have kept their weapons despite numerous orders by the Kenyan government to surrender their guns. A recent announcement that the state planned to enact a law so that anyone found with illegal guns faced life imprisonment made no difference. 

Yussuf Dogo, an official at a local non-governmental organisation, Friends of Nomads International, said orders by the government and harsh security measures intended to retrieve the guns would not succeed but only lead to further violation of human rights. 


Photo: Siegfried Modola/IRIN 
A armed man guards his herd in northwestern Kenya
"It is very unfair to punish or brand as violent a community for protecting itself," Dogo said. "Every human being and even wild animals have an obligation to protect themselves." 

He suggested that maintaining security in the vast region could be easier and cheaper if the local communities were involved - a view shared by Samburu councillor Daniel Legerded. 

According to Legerded, the Samburu pastoralists suffered more than 20 attacks after they surrendered 2,000 guns to the government in 2006. 

"Security men were deployed to the affected areas but they did not stop the attacks; many people were killed," he said. "It is obvious Samburus will not repeat the mistake [of handing back guns]." 

Blame game 

Like many residents in the area, he blamed the government for failing to contain inter-communal conflicts in northern Kenya, claiming there was selective disarmament. "Our neighbours were not forced to surrender guns and even the state provided them with guns and police reservists after their leaders pledged to support the government," he claimed. "They have used them to attack us." 

However, Hussein Sasura, Member of Parliament for Marsabit constituency and assistant government minister for public works, said guns issued by the government for containing security in the region had been abused. 

This had aggravated conflict in the region, he added, citing the 30 people who had died in gun fights in Marsabit over the past two months. 

"We have two types of guns: those owned illegally and those issued by the government - they are all causing chaos," Sasura told IRIN. "Police reservists have been recruited; it is a noble idea, but the process and procedure must be reviewed." 

''We have two types of guns: those owned illegally and those issued by the government - they are all causing chaos''
"Women and children cannot access water points because they are threatened with guns issued by the state," Sasura said. "It must stop." 

Marsabit district commissioner Mutea Iringo said the possession of illegal guns could not be justified, insisting that government had tried to restore and maintain peace in the vast region. Guns, he insisted, were not the solution to the insecurity that had affected the pastoralists. 

Iringo's view was echoed by Chachu Tadicha, a peace campaigner in Marsabit. Attributing the persistent conflicts in the region to several factors, he said peace could only be ensured through a campaign for non-violence, youth empowerment and provision of more water points and livestock markets. 

Illegal weapons are neither registered with the police or military, nor licensed to civilians. Observers say Kenya's northern region lies along a gun-trafficking corridor that stretches from Somalia to southern Sudan and northern Uganda. 

Last week, authorities in the Kenyan capital, Nairobi, destroyed 8,000 weapons recovered by the police over the past few months. This brought to 12,000 the total number of illegal weapons destroyed in the country over the past few years, but at least 100,000 are still believed to be in circulation, against 4,000 that are properly licensed. 

Across East Africa and the Horn of Africa, more than 600,000 illegal weapons are in circulation. According to Francis Sang, executive secretary of the Nairobi-based Regional Centre on Small Arms, the most common are the G-3 and AK47 rifles, as well as pistols such as the US Colt, Browning, Beretta and revolvers. 

na/eo/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Hundreds displaced in “drought” clashes

ISIOLO, 18 September 2008 (IRIN) - 
At least six people have been killed and hundreds displaced following days of fighting over water and pasture along the Isiolo and Samburu district border as drought-related conflict escalated in northern Kenya.

"We have so far managed to find six bodies but still suspect that more bodies might be lying in the bush," Marius Tum, a senior police superintendent in Isiolo, told IRIN. The bodies were riddled with bullets.

"More attacks were reported last night ... the animals that were too weak to be moved were also shot," Raphael Lekilua, a local Samburu leader, said. The fighting was between Borana and Samburu herders.

The conflict has also led to population displacement. "People have moved away from Kom and Sabarwaiwai, which are the only available grazing areas," Lekilua said. The two areas are reserved for grazing when there is a drought.

The livestock will die if the government does not help [those who have fled] return, he said, adding that at least 200 Samburu families have fled.

"The fighting is a struggle over water and pasture, nothing else. Each group is trying to uproot the other from the area," Ahmed Mohamed, an official of a local NGO, the Nomadic Support and Rehabilitation Programme, told IRIN.

Mohamed said at least 1,000 people had been displaced in Isiolo. "They require urgent assistance to return to the field, which must be shared by all the nomadic pastoralists in the region."

The fighting, he said, was also causing food shortages as livestock milk production had dropped.

Security personnel have been deployed to the affected areas of Kom and Sabarwaiwai.

The northern Kenya region is experiencing severe drought, which has led to an escalation of conflict over scarce resources among the predominantly pastoralist population.

At least 13 people were recently killed in inter-clan clashes over water in the neighbouring region of Mandera.

na/aw/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Clashes leave nine dead, several injured

ISIOLO, 5 June 2009 (IRIN) - 
At least nine people have been reported dead and several injured following a livestock raid and clashes between communities along the northern Isiolo-Samburu district border. Tension remains high in the area, with ongoing fighting, according to the Kenya Red Cross Society (KRCS).

"The dead include three police officers, five civilians and a police reservist," Nelly Muluka, KRCS public relations and communications officer, told IRIN. "Eleven policemen who suffered soft tissue injuries and eight others with bullet wounds were admitted to the Isiolo District Hospital."

The deaths occurred on 2 June after police officers, who had intervened following reports of a raid in Isiolo, allegedly by Turkana or Samburu raiders, were attacked. Some 815 head of cattle, 500 goats and 36 camels were reported stolen.

The deaths and loss of livestock triggered the clashes pitting the Borana and Somali communities against the Samburu and Turkana. Affected areas include Chasagafarfa, Daaba and Mulango along the outskirts of Isiolo town, said Muluka.

However, Isiolo District Commissioner, Kimani Waweru, told IRIN that five people had been killed, adding that cattle rustling and the current drought had sparked the clashes.

"We have deployed additional police officers and home guards... the raiders are also being pursued, I am confident they will be arrested and the stolen livestock recovered," said Waweru.

According to Muluka, the number of displaced remains unknown. She said KRCS was liaising with the Ministry of Health and the district commissioner and was providing vehicles to transport the injured.

Security fears 
Meanwhile, transport services between Isiolo town and the affected areas has been disrupted, with operators along the neighbouring Marsabit and Moyale routes afraid of being attacked.

Mukhtar Sheikh, a resident of one of the affected areas, told IRIN in Isiolo Town that some families were camping in the open at the local Sharp trading centre.

Heads of livestock have also been abandoned by fleeing owners, he said. "The situation is bad; I left my 46 goats and eight cattle that were too weak to move, I thank Allah I survived the attack," Sheikh said.

Drought-related conflicts have worsened in pastoral regions in the recent past with dozens of people dying. Shortages of food and water brought on by the impact of climate change could escalate existing conflicts and generate others, according to experts.

na/aw/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Livestock dying as drought deepens

ISIOLO/MANDERA, 6 April 2011 (IRIN) - Thousands more heads of livestock have died in Kenya’s arid Northeastern province as La Niña drought conditions worsen and water shortages become more acute. 

Drought monitoring and assessment reports indicate that the hardest-hit areas are Marsabit, Moyale and Mandera. Livestock farmers in the three regions have lost more than 17,000 animals since January, according to officials from the Kenya Red Cross Society (KRCS) and the government’s Arid Lands and Resource Management Project (ALRMP).

Mass deaths of livestock began in February, but the average daily loss of animals has risen in the last three weeks as crucial water sources dried up. Many of the remaining water sources are contaminated, leading to increased incidents of water-borne diseases such as typhoid, amoeba and diarrhoea.

A recent assessment by the UN found that the drought ravaging East Africa had left eight million needing food aid, 1.2 million in Kenya.

KRCS Marsabit coordinator, Abdi Malik, told IRIN that many families are becoming increasingly vulnerable to hunger and hardships related to the crisis. “The most recent assessment conducted on the drought clearly shows that the situation is very serious compared to conditions in January,” he said. “More than 70 percent of an estimated 300,000 people are affected now and the figure will rise unless it rains. We expect more animal deaths. Thousands are weak and the few water sources are drying up. Pasture everywhere is exhausted.”

He added that the water shortage and depletion of boreholes had led to a mass migration of pastoralist families from Marsabit and Moyale to Forole in Ethiopia. He said the Red Cross was providing water to primary schools to prevent their closure and to support supplementary feeding programmes.

Jirma Duba, a resident from Marsabit, said water shortages had caused deadly conflicts. Fighting between the Rendille, Borana and Gabra communities over scarce water sources and grazing areas have resulted in the deaths of 12 people. A number of resource-related killings was also reported along the Isiolo and Samburu borders.

Thousands of residents from Mandera have also migrated from grazing areas and trading centres, according to the Rural Agency for Community Development and Assistance (RACIDA). Mohamed Dualle, coordinator of RACIDA, fears the situation will be even worse in April.

“We have not received a single drop of rain and yet the rains were expected two weeks ago. We are faced with a humanitarian crisis. A significant number of deaths, mainly of children, pregnant women and elderly people can be attributed to hunger, dehydration and lack of water,” he said. “Banisa, a rich grazing area and a trading centre with more than 18,000 people and surrounded by 16 villages, is almost deserted now. The only dam which has served the whole population for last seven years dried up last week.”

He added that livestock owners with large herds of animals had migrated to the nearest water point, 123km away, and livestock traders that have lost their businesses are also likely to move.


Photo: Anthony Morland/IRIN 
Migration of pastoralists with their livestock has led to a shortage of animals in local markets
Rising prices
The World Food Programme (WFP) hasappealed for more funds to deal with the crisis in the coming months. Josette Sheeran, the director, said WFP “has only 44 percent of the resources it needs to feed 5.22 million people in Kenya, Somalia, Ethiopia, Djibouti and the Karamoja region of eastern Uganda from April to September”. 

An increase in staple food prices, particularly in far-flung areas, has worsened the situation in Kenya, according to ALRMP: 1kg of beans in Sericho, Isiolo, has increased from 50 shillings to 80 shillings (US60 cents to about $1) since January and milk has risen from 40 shillings (50 cents) per litre to 60 shillings (72 cents) per litre.

Mass migration of pastoralists with their livestock has led to a shortage of animals in local markets, triggering a price increase and a loss of income for those whose livelihoods depend on the trade. In Mandera, Wajir and Garissa, households have had to sell three to four goats to purchase a 90kg bag of maize, rather than the average of one or two goats.

Hussein Ali, a local leader and an elder from Jericho, said water was even more costly than food in the area. “A 20l can of water is selling at 60 shillings. It’s more expensive than a kilo of maize flour,” said Ali. “A number of families have sent their children to the Daadab refugee camps to be registered as aliens from Somalia in order to get relief food.”

The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said drought conditions, once periodic in nature, had now become a “predictable emergency” and an emergency response was no longer sustainable. Pastoralist leaders said large-scale measures adopted by the government to address the crisis were insufficient and unsuccessful.

na/zm/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

ETHIOPIA: Help "trickling in” for millions needing food aid

ADDIS ABABA, 6 May 2011 (IRIN) 
- The Ethiopian government has started receiving food and non-food aid for hundreds of thousands of vulnerable people in the country's southern and south-eastern lowlands after an appeal in April, Agriculture Minister Mitiku Kassa told IRIN.

"Based on their interests, donors' reactions to our latest appeal varies; we have received cash for non-food requirements while food is being donated in kind for the food needs," Mitiku said. "We had carried over from 2010 so now we are doing an overall assessment on what the donors' response has been and to know where we stand after the latest response."

The Ethiopian government and aid agencies said at least two million people required urgent relief aid in the southern and south-eastern lowlands, which received poor rains due to the La Niña weather phenomenon.

"According to the revised resource requirements associated with the increasing needs identified, an estimated US$75,030,109 is required to respond to food and non-food needs during the months of April and May 2011," the Ministry of Agriculture said in a 12 April report.

The report said the total quantity required to address food requirements for April and May 2011 was 76,292MT, which is estimated to cost $53,404,677. “Considering the available resources valued at $8,521,800, the net requirement is $44,882,877.”

The La Niña-affected parts of the country include all the nine zones of the Somali region; Borana and parts of Bale, Guji, Arsi, East and West Hararghe zones of Oromia region; and South Omo, Konso and Derashe Special Woreda of Southern region, while there are increasing reports of drought effects from northern Afar.

Livestock prices falling

According to a special report published on 27 April by the Ethiopia Humanitarian Country Team (EHCT), pasture and traditional water sources have been depleted in most of the affected areas.

"Animal body condition is declining rapidly, resulting in lower livestock prices at market even as the price of staple cereals is increasing," the EHCT report indicated.


Photo: Anthony Mitchell/IRIN 
Pasture and traditional water sources have been depleted in most of the areas affected by the La Niña weather phenomenon
According to the EHCT, which comprises UN agencies, international and national NGOs and donors, the conflict in the Middle East and North Africa has resulted in lower demand for cattle exports from Ethiopia, while global food and fuel price increases have hiked the cost of buying and importing foodstuffs and other essential goods.

In its latest report of 6 April, Ethiopia's Central Statistical Agency said the annual inflation rate soared to 25 percent in March from 16.5 percent in February.

While non-food inflation rate reached 24.3 percent from 22 percent in the same period, food inflation showed the largest jump in more than two years, reaching 25.5 percent in March from 12.8 percent in February.

"With the end of the long gu/ganna rainy season in pastoral areas fast approaching at the end of April, a second consecutive season of very poor rains is increasingly likely," said the EHCT.

Emergency conditions are said to be likely to persist until the next rainy season, due in October.

According to Kristen Knutson, spokeswoman for the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, the needs assessment for the coming season is scheduled to start in early May and run for 15 days.

However, the Ethiopian government says there are positive signs as the rains have started in some areas, despite the outlook for the southern and south-eastern lowlands.

"Almost all parts of Somali region and parts of Oromia region, for example, have received rains in recent days; this is a very positive sign as most of the food insecurity in such pastoralist areas comes from the shortage of water," said Akloweg Nigatu, information officer at the Agriculture Ministry.

Akloweg said vegetation should start flourishing after the rain, providing food for camels, which are a source of food for pastoralists.

kt/js/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Tuesday, April 22, 2014

ETHIOPIA-KENYA: Who rules the range?

For pastoral communities, the rangeland is perceived as a single, communally-owned economic resource (file photo)
LONDON, 24 October 2011 (IRIN) - The border land between Kenya and Ethiopia is a vast, open plain under a big sky. Hard red earth shows through the thin grass of the sun-baked landscape, an expanse of thorny scrub, flat-topped thorn-trees and tall red anthills. There are no fences or other visible boundaries, and few people, just occasional groups of cattle or goats with their herders. To the untutored eye it can look like empty land, where wandering nomads graze their animals at random.

But there is nothing random about it. This unpromising landscape can provide a good living for livestock if it is carefully managed, and the herds are kept on the move across the seasons so they make the optimum use of each area of pasture and each water source. Over the years, the herders have built up a great body of expertise about how best to manage the area's resources.

And the land is also definitely not "empty" in the sense that it belongs to no one - the people of the area are quite clear about whose land is whose, in terms not of individuals, but of different communities.

Sara Pavanello, who has just completed a three-year study of how natural resources are managed in the area, says: "The pastoralists I spoke to very often used collective terms, saying for example, 'Our resources, we decide, we manage…' For pastoral communities, the rangeland as a whole is perceived as one single economic resource that’s communally owned, even if this tract of rangeland has been divided by the international border. At the same time different ethnic groups own, or exercise control over specific territory and the natural resources found within it."

This does not mean that they exclude everyone else. They understand that other groups need access to the pasture and water sources at certain seasons. That kind of temporary access is traditionally negotiated between the elders of the different communities. Elders told Pavanello: "Today they need us; tomorrow we will need them." She describes this kind of sharing as being seen as an "insurance policy for the future".

Land ownership conundrum 

It is a model that makes perfect sense to the Borana, Gabra and Garri, the three ethnic groups which live along and across the border, but one that the conventional authorities struggle with, both in Ethiopia and Kenya. Land in Kenya is, for the most part, in private ownership. In Ethiopia all land belongs to the people, represented by the state. Neither system is designed to cope with private land, communally owned.

In Ethiopia, farmers are granted land to cultivate, and have security of possession under the constitution. Pavanello and her co-author, Simon Levine, say pastoralists’ rights are much weaker. The constitution gives them the right to use free land for grazing but, they write "the operative word here is free; the moment the state chooses to claim any grazing land, and declare it no longer 'free' the pastoralists lose any right to graze."

The authorities also tend to want to introduce resource management schemes to make the rangelands more productive, failing to see and understand the subtle and flexible management systems already in place involving elders and community institutions.

In their research Pavanello and Levine found cases where local administrators were enforcing ideas of ownership, citizenship and nationality which cut across the communities’ traditional right to manage their lands. In Kenya they say district officials reportedly cited the principle of freedom of movement for Kenyan citizens under the constitution in order to allow Somali clans into the rangelands of Borana clans around Moyale, despite the elders’ protests that it would exhaust the grazing.


On the other side of the border Ethiopia’s policy of "ethnic federalism" puts the Garri in Somali Region and the Borana in Orommiya, and has led, say Pavanello and Levine, to administrators pressing pastoralist communities to adopt a more exclusionary approach to natural resources, failing, they say, “to recognize the fact that granting secondary users rights of access is in customary law a legal obligation, which reinforces, rather than undermines the primary holders' claims of ownership rights and sovereignty over their territory”.

Cross-border mixed committees

The challenge is clearly how to harmonize traditional and formal regulation in a way which allows the flexibility and freedom of movement on which the productivity of the rangelands depends. Here the paper focuses on the growth of cross-border mixed committees on which both local government officials and community elders are represented, along with other groups such as young people and women. Set up mostly to deal with cattle raiding, the committees have also had some success in the joint management of pasture and water resources in the border areas, with communities from both sides sharing the resources and jointly negotiating access for other groups.

The idea of these mixed committees generated a lot of interest at the launch of the report earlier this month at London’s Overseas Development Institute. Jeremy Swift, a pastoralist development specialist with a lifetime of experience in the field, said bringing formal and customary regulation together was necessary, but likely to be difficult. "Formal rules have to be uniform throughout the country; customary rules are place and time specific. This is only likely to work if there is a real delegation of authority, which governments are not usually happy about and not likely to do willingly."

John Morton of the University of Greenwich cautioned against any attempt to bypass formal government structures. "Clearly this border is very fluid, but the states are still real, and you have to respect state authority and boundaries. You don’t do people any favours by over-stressing cross-border action which may label pastoralists as having divided loyalties."

The co-author of the report, Simon Levine, said they also had some reservations about the hybrid committees. "For example, in a case where it is the committee which decides who can use a water point, you are in effect negating the idea that the people who used to call themselves the owners of that land now have the right to exclude anyone. Now that may be a good thing or it may be a bad thing, but it does seem to me that it is not necessarily always going to be a good thing, especially where you know that the power relations within the committee may not always be equal… I would have thought the idea of hybrid committees is possibly and hopefully a way forward, but one that needs an awful lot more caution than I heard expressed today."

eb/cb
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Demo Hassan, "For 40 years, food aid has been routine"



Photo: Noor Ali/IRIN
Hassan Demo says free food has encouraged laziness

GARBATULLA, 26 August 2011 (IRIN) - 

The humanitarian response to Kenya's current food crisis may be unusual in its scale and media attention but there is nothing new about food aid in northern Kenya, where lack of development, insecurity, population growth and recurrent drought have long combined to undermine self-sufficiency. Several million people there receive food aid as a matter of course. Demo Hassan, 66, a livestock trader in Garbatulla, gives voice to the dependency problem theory, the idea that such largesse feeds a vicious cycle.

"Today, a lorry loaded with sacks of maize, government relief supplies, came here. It is okay [in the current context] but I often get sad when I see trucks loaded with free food.

"For over 40 years, the supply of relief food to my Borana community has been routine whether it rains or not. It started after independence [1963] to support families whose animals were shot dead by government security forces or confiscated during the Shifta war [1963-1968] to secede this region to be a part of Somalia.

"[Then it] was justified because it helped desperate families who had lost their animals, their source of livelihood.

"Now, periodic droughts, massive losses of animals and frequent conflicts in this region are being used to justify heavy spending [on] emergency relief food.

"But [relief food] is not the only way to help a community, it has not helped any recipient to be rich, it has deprived us of our dignity and killed our diverse talents.

"The free food has encouraged laziness; people just wait for the food rations. 

"The youth, energetic men and women, who used to engage in livestock trade, work as herders, do crop faming and small business like selling milk and animals, have all abandoned their work [to] idle around and wait for free food.

"Some traders have closed their shops, as they have nobody to buy food from them and are now some of the latest [food aid] recipients.

"Free food has dignified the habit of begging. 

"It is common to see able-bodied men visiting NGO and government offices to beg for relief food yet they can feed themselves and their families, do manual work, farm or form a group to borrow money to start a small business.

"Through my community's campaign, Stop Free Food, we can change perceptions about the arid lands. We are lobbying for alternative programmes that can be started after the current severe drought. 

"We can start by planning, identifying the talents of the [food aid] recipients. Why should they be given free food permanently?

"We have many livestock traders like me who can be assisted with funds to purchase large herds of animals, hire trucks and sell them to far-away, profitable markets in Nairobi [the capital] and other towns.

"Many families can resume crop farming. All they need is seeds and water pipes to supply water by gravity from the permanent rivers in [the] Kinna, Rapsu and Gafarsa areas. 

"Farmers require trucks to ferry their produce to the market rather than feed their animals with some of the produce like in the past.

"Our district is endowed with a lot of resources; honey production and eco-tourism are all possible. 

"[But] I am worried about our children dropping out of school to join their parents in waiting for relief food. Aid agencies should offer full bursaries to our children; a lot of talent has been wasted due to this disgusting habit of waiting to be fed.

"We need tertiary institutions here as we have a huge youth potential.

"I am sure my grandchildren will not require relief food as my two children, who are in college, will get good jobs."

na/aw/am/mw

[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

ETHIOPIA: Borena zone braced for more failed rains


Livestock carcasses dot southern Borena zone of Oromiya region
BORENA (OROMIYA REGION), 18 July 2011 (IRIN) - Last October, the elders in Borena zone of Oromiya region in southern Ethiopia predicted that the main rains would fail but some never took them seriously. The same happened in February.

“There were some who believed them and sold their livestock and bought goats and saved up some of their money," Uka Dida, chairman of the Dembi kebele (village), said. “I did not believe them and I lost all my livestock – it was an expensive lesson for me.”

Now, the elders are warning that the second rains will fail again in October. Their calculations are based on the phases of the moon and the position of the stars. This time local officials believe the forecast.

"We don't have good meteorological services here - the elders also do their calculations and what they tell us is not good news,” said Ephrem Ombosho, head of one of several Disaster Prevention and Preparedness Agency offices in Borena. He and his team are assessing local needs.

Like other pastoralists in the region, the Borana have a range of techniques to anticipate and even predict drought, some based on observing natural phenomena such as the growth of shoots on particular plants at certain times in the year. Their calendar system, which is based on observations of the moon and stars and is thought by researchers to date back to 300BC, incorporates a form of astrology and weather forecasting.

In search of pasture 

According to the UN, the southern Borena zone, along with other parts of the Horn of Africa, is just one step away from famine, on a five-point scale.

"We are thinking of forming cooperatives to pool our money for a difficult time like this," Uka said. "We are also advising people to invest in goats, which are more drought-tolerant, and maybe give up on cattle now.”

Villagers such as Adan Dhono, who lost 25 animals, have set off on a two-week journey by foot, with his surviving seven cattle, for greener pastures more than 200km away.

Others try to find casual work across the border in Kenya, but the situation is not any better there. Officials say at least 20 percent of Borena’s population has migrated to other neighbouring zones. “But imagine the amount of overgrazing that is going to lead to,” an aid worker said.

There are two rainy seasons in Oromiya: the main season, October-November, and the small season, February-May. Both failed in Borena, destroying thousands of livestock and the lives of those who depend on them. The number of aid beneficiaries has risen by 41 percent in July since April 2011, says the government.

It is cooler now in Borena. Dark clouds hover, "but these clouds just pass us by every time this year - they are moving from Kenya towards the highlands, they are not for us", said Seifu Mekbib, an agricultural expert with the local administration in Moyale, the border town between Ethiopia and Kenya.

Without rain, there is a chance some livestock will not recover. Of the 1.29 million people in Borena, at least 412,000 are already receiving some kind of food assistance, including aid provided under the Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP).

Livestock deaths

Only a month ago, the stench from the rotting carcasses of cattle, donkeys and even chickens pervaded southern Borena. "The heat and the smell were so tremendous – it was very difficult for us to move around," an aid worker told IRIN.

A villager at Dikicha, about 20km from Ethiopia’s southern border with Kenya, pointed to a long ditch, with the remains of livestock. IRIN visited four villages. All had similar stories - hundreds of livestock dead.

"We just don’t have the resources to compensate their loss – it will take at least two years for them to recover," said Amare Endale, a health official at the local Disaster Prevention and Preparedness Agency office. "Some NGOs like Care International and the Food and Agriculture Organization have provided money but that support is also limited by resources.”

Some livestock farmers, who had received compensation, said the amount was not adequate to replace the dead animal. “I got 800 birr [about US$47] for a cow, while the cost to replace it is 1,500 birr [about $88.50],” said Boru Iba, a member of a village association.

The government’s PSNP targets people facing predictable food insecurity and offers guaranteed employment for five days a month in return for food or cash, but it has run its course in Borena. The programme runs for six months every year and also assists the elderly and disabled.


Photo: Jaspreet Kindra/IRIN
Relief beneficiaries want more than just cereals. This photo was taken at a PSNP distribution point in the Borena zone
Anger 

In Moyale town, the last distribution of food under the PSNP has left some angry. Dhebo Giro, 60, resident of Shabare village, asked: “What are we going to do for the next three months and what if it does not rain in October?”

People were also incensed that they were only getting cereals. “We cannot afford salt, oil; I don’t even have water – I am a woman, I need water but I can only bathe once a month,” added Dhebo.

But Hussein Hassen, a field monitor with the UN World Food Programme (WFP), which provides the food for the programme, said resources were limited.

Because of the high food prices, he said, efforts were being made to ensure pastoralist communities got food rather than cash.

Admissions to the therapeutic feeding programmes in Oromiya increased by 37 percent between February and March, according to the government’s Revised Humanitarian Requirements Document.

Ombosho, the local disaster official, said relief food would be increased, but the numbers in need were rapidly rising.

In Demdi village, those numbers had doubled in the past three months, according to Barude Gideso, a food security expert at a Disaster Prevention and Preparedness Agency office. As a result, the amount of corn soya blend per beneficiary had been reduced from about 4kg to about 1kg.

jk/js/eo/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More

 
Powered by Blogger