Showing posts with label Governance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Governance. Show all posts

Thursday, April 24, 2014

ETHIOPIA-KENYA: Rebel group wreaks havoc in northeast Kenya

Armed rebels are a constant source of fear for civilians in northeast Kenya (file photo)
MOYALE, 23 December 2010 (IRIN) - 
The presence of an Ethiopian rebel group in northern Kenya, coupled with operations by security forces from both countries, has caused numerous casualties and displacement among local residents, who also complain of arbitrary arrests.

"They are a menace," Moyale District Commissioner David Rotich said of the secessionist Oromo Liberation Front (OLF), which first rose up against Ethiopian authorities three decades ago.

"They pose a major threat to security and development and are linked to a group of gun dealers and poachers across the region," he alleged.

Residents of Moyale, Isiolo and Marsabit districts told IRIN that civilians were often detained by security agents who accused them of belonging to the OLF, or harassed by the rebels on suspicion of collaborating with the authorities.

Terror

A trader at Walda centre in Sololo, Moyale district, said several business people had to close their operations because of a wave of terror acts allegedly arising from the OLF presence in the area.

"Walda trading centre is a risky and difficult area to do business because it is considered the main military base for OLF rebels; Ethiopian troops frequently attack us while pursuing the rebel fighters who also attack, abduct, kill and threaten local residents," the trader said.

Identifying himself only as Wario, a hotelier at Turbi - where at least 80 people were killed four years ago - said the OLF, often comprising Kenyans and Ethiopians, once ordered him close his restaurant business because of his ethnicity.

"Our county council and government issues permits and licences for all traders to conduct business but [I believe] OLF makes the final decision; I was forced to close my restaurant because my crime was simple, I am a Gabra and therefore considered an enemy," Wario said.

Most of the OLF fighters in northern Kenya are from the Borana community.

A retired chief from Sololo said: "The OLF was at first a pride to the Borana community but it is now a monster; it has killed many of our neighbours."

On 15 December, 15 people died in Moyale and Marsabit districts after fierce fighting between the OLF and a splinter group in Badarero, Walda and Kate areas.

A Turbi resident, identified only as Ndege, said hundreds of families from his Gabra community remained displaced.

"We have suffered greatly at the hands of OLF; many people have been killed, many families are poor after losing their livestock to OLF, many have moved far away to look for manual work, other are recipients of relief food, beggars in towns and some young orphaned girls have been forced to work as commercial sex workers," Ndege said.

Police operations
In November, Kenya police launched an operation to flush out the OLF rebels. However, residents said dozens of innocent youth were netted in the operation.

Moyale police commander Nathaniel Langat, told IRIN: "We have intelligence reports, what we are doing now is very different from the past operations, it has achieved a lot, the rebels have fled, many have crossed to Ethiopia, the government could not just sit and watch its citizens being killed, abducted and threatened by this bandits."

Wenslas Ong’ayo, the Upper Eastern province regional commissioner, said the operation was being conducted "with a human face" and that no incidents had been reported so far. He added that all those arrested were found with weapons and had no permission to be in the country.

However, Wajir human rights network official Mukhtar Nur said an assessment conducted by the group established that local residents were living in fear of security forces and rebel fighters roaming the area.

"Young herders are no longer going out to look after their animals for fear of arrests," he said. "Women are also afraid to go out to look for water or firewood because some have been arrested along the way, held the whole day and accused of ferrying supplies to the rebels."

• Meanwhile, in Nairobi, some 200 ethnic Oromos from Ethiopia complained of police harassment at a protest rally on 23 December.

“The police come to our houses in the middle of the night, abusing women, ripping up our refugee documents,” Tsegaye Gudeta, spokesman for the Oromo Refugee Community Welfare Association, told IRIN.

“Besides detention, some of us are facing daily disappearances and abuse. We were afraid for our lives, have no other place to go and we couldn’t wait any more,” he added.

The protest was held outside the UN Refugee Agency, which Gudeta said should work with Kenyan police to increase awareness of refugees’ rights.

na/js/cm/am/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Cattle-rustling and the politics of business in Kenya

NAIROBI, 27 March 2014 (IRIN) - 
Cattle raiding in Kenya is often viewed in the legitimizing context of tradition, climate change and resource conflict, but increasingly it has much more to do with organized crime meeting a rising demand for meat, and political violence resulting from a new devolutionary constitution.

The human cost of raids is immense: hundreds are killed every year and many thousands forcibly displaced.

Two sources within the Anti-Stock Theft Unit, a division of the Kenya police charged with preventing cattle theft, told IRIN that an estimated 580 people were killed between January 2012 and January 2014 as a result of cattle raids.

The cattle raids by armed young men involve attacks on rival ethnic groups or clans. At times, raiders come from neighbouring countries such as South Sudan and Ethiopia. But while traditional cattle-rustling did not always involve killing, it is now invariably lethal.

Increasingly, some argue, cattle-raiding is motivated by a competition for political power and resources: political barons use organized attacks to drive out their political rivals and extend their business interests.

“The [2010] constitution heavily devolved power and resources to the grassroots and this has in turn increased competition for political power and resources in formerly marginalized areas and, as such, issues like cattle-rustling have transformed from being cultural to a tool to perpetuate power and violence,” Betty Budho, a political analyst at the University of Nairobi, told IRIN.

She added: “I believe in northern Kenya, it would be foolhardy for anybody to view cattle raids in isolation and forget the political and economic motivations for it. With devolution, the power struggles between pastoralists have become common.”

According to the authors of a 2014 report entitled On the margin: Kenya’s pastoralists, such struggles peaked during the 2013 elections, the first to be held under the devolutionary constitution, in which significant powers are decentralized to 47 new counties, under influential governors.

In a country where political allegiance is driven far more by ethnicity than ideology, “communities competed against each other for representation, and particularly for the role of governor,” the report explained.

“A tribe’s local dominance can swing a local election, and in some areas smaller ones formed alliances such as the Rendille, Gabra and Burji (REGABU), which was established to counter the dominant Borana in Marsabit. Whether the outcome is the rule of one dominant tribe at the exclusion of others, or a coalition of minority tribes ruling over a dominant one, there is an inherent risk of instability and tension,” it said.

Marsabit is a remote and historically marginalized district of northern Kenya.

In a 2013 paper entitled Guns, Land, and Votes: Cattle Rustling and the Politics of Boundary(re)making in northern Kenya, Clemens Greiner argued that there is a disguised relationship between politics and cattle raids.

“The erosion of traditional governance structures has led to a power vacuum that is increasingly filled by political leaders and other power brokers who grasp the opportunity to renegotiate boundaries and access to land…

“They have realized that on the national level ethnic mobilization has played a major role in political struggles, and they carry these dynamics even into the remotest pastoralist areas, where the struggle for land is progressively ethnicized. In this context, livestock raiding emerges as a specific form of violent regulation: a well-adapted, dangerous, and powerful political weapon,” he said.

According to Josephat Nanok, the governor of the northwestern county of Turkana where cattle raids are common, “Continuing to treat [cattle-rustling] like a cultural practice is akin to condoning an illegal business. It has been highly commercialized and many politicians are now using it to create support zones for themselves,” he told IRIN.

“The political connection to me, explains the reason such raids occur with more frequency during elections,” Nanok added.

Enoch Mwani, an agricultural economist at the University of Nairobi, says local pastoralists are no longer the only ones involved in cattle-rustling.

“Cattle-rustling has always been an activity to replenish herd stock but it isn’t [just] that any more. Cattle raids in the lawless Horn of Africa are driven by the desire by those communities to get money to buy arms, and by business people who want to cash in on a growing urban population in need of meat,” Mwani said.

“That some still do it as a cultural practice isn’t completely false, but it isn’t completely true either. Tribal conflicts are common and communities need arms to protect themselves when the governments fail to do so, and meat traders provide an easy source of money to buy arms,” he added.

Commercialized cattle-rustling

Trade in livestock is big business. According to the Global Forum on Agricultural Research, Kenya will have a beef deficit of about 4,500 tons in 2014 due to high local consumption and export demands.

The Kenya Meat Commission estimates that some 500 tons of beef are exported from Kenya each week to the Middle East (United Arab Emirates, Kuwait, Qatar and Saudi Arabia) and Africa (Egypt, Tanzania, Uganda, Democratic Republic of Congo and Sudan).

“In many areas we do observe an intensifying shift from a `breeding herd’ [rearing for prestige] to a ‘trading herd’ [rearing for sale] - in part to take advantage of the growing markets for animals and livestock products in urban areas as well as export markets,” Jeremy Lind, pastoral theme convener at the Future Agricultures Consortium and research fellow at the UK Institute for Development Studies, told IRIN.

“Small-town growth in the dry lands has also influenced changes in livestock marketing dynamics. Small butchers and micro-dairying operations have proliferated in many towns in [Kenya and other regional countries] to meet the demand for meat and milk in these areas from sedentary herders as well as migrants who have come from other areas.”

The authors of a 2011 paper on the effects of cattle-rustling and household characteristics on migration decisions and herd size among pastoralists in Kenya’s western Baringo District, noted that “there is an emergence of commercialized cattle-rustling where wealthy businessmen, politicians, traders or local people pursuing economic objectives finance raids among the pastoral communities.”

A 2010 study commissioned by the Kenya Human Rights Commission also echoed this view, claiming that “the meat-loving urbanite Kenyans are the unsuspecting accomplices of these unscrupulous businessmen.”

Livestock markets like Karangware, an informal settlement in Nairobi, are thriving. Transporters from Moyale, a border town near Ethiopia, come to a slaughterhouse here to offload cattle, sheep and goats.

“We will travel back to Garissa tomorrow by bus to bring more goats. The demand here in Nairobi is very big. We are making good money from this business,” Abdi Farah, 24, told IRIN. Farah earns 100 Kenya shillings (US$1.15) for every animal he brings to the city but, he says, transporters like him never find out the source of the animals that he delivers.

“We know some of the livestock is stolen but we just buy because we want the best price. Stolen cattle are sold much cheaper,” Farah said.

Regional dimension

Hussein Mahmoud, a professor at Pwani University (60km north of Mombasa) and expert on the livestock trade, notes that in the region, illegal rustling is transnational and stolen livestock is taken across borders into neighbouring countries.

Cattle raids and trade also have a connection to regional conflicts. A 2008 paperby Alemmaya Mulugeta, a researcher at the University of Basel, noted: “In the Horn of Africa’s pastoral peripheries cattle raids have been intertwined with strongly militarized conflicts such as civil wars and cross-border disputes.”

There are historical antecedents to cross-border cattle rustling. The Kenya Human Rights Commission report observes there was “an upsurge of cattle raids between the Ugandan Karamajong and Turkanas of Kenya” caused by the sudden availability of weapons after the Karamajong overran the armoury in Moroto at the fall of Idi Amin’s regime in 1979.

But, the report argued that ongoing internal strife in neighbouring countries makes getting rid of illegal weapons to reduce deaths from cattle-rustling an uphill battle. “It is practically impossible to conduct an effective disarmament exercise without effectively engaging the neighbouring countries.”

ko/aps/cb/oa
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Briefing: Escalating clashes in northern Kenya

Photo: Kenya Red Cross 
Damaged houses in Moyale in the aftermath of inter-ethnic conflict (file photo)
MOYALE, 11 December 2013 (IRIN) - 
A fresh outbreak of violence between communities in northern Kenya’s Moyale area – in Marsabit County - has displaced tens of thousands and led the government to take the almost unprecedented step of deploying its troops domestically in an effort to quell the unrest.

The violence, which has broken out intermittently since late 2011, has paralysed business and transport activities.

The attacks have often been abrupt in nature, targeting people at work or who are travelling, according to a 9 December Kenya Red Cross Society (KRCS)update .

There have been incidents of roads being barricaded, as well. On 28 November, transport between Moyale and Nairobi was cut off after the road was blocked at the Turbi area for over 10 hours, notes KRCS.

What is the current humanitarian situation?

As of 11 December, at least 72,000 people in Moyale have been uprooted from their homes,  according to KRCS, which notes that about a third of the displaced families have crossed the border into Ethiopia, after violence left at least 30 people dead in the previous week.

"More than 10 settlements have been completely deserted. We found no single soul in all the areas hard-hit by the clashes. All families have left and fled," Tom Omolo, KRCS’s regional disaster coordinator, told IRIN.  Some of the abandoned areas include the villages of Arosa, Butiye, Funanyata, Kote, Oda and Sololo.

Wario Lakicha, whose family is among those that have fled into Ethiopia, said: "We are suffering. Nobody is helping us. In some cases, more than 30 people are sharing one house; a large number are being hosted by relatives."

Also newly in Ethiopia, Wario Golicha, who fled the village of Butiye, told IRIN that his family is living in a flimsy structure made of polythene. For a toilet, the family is using the open fields. "We have no water, no food, no blankets, mosquito nets or bed, and sleep in darkness. My children have no clothes - they left them all as we fled," he said.

We have no water, no food, no blankets, mosquito nets or bed, and sleep in darkness. My children have no clothes - they left them all as we fled 
Several families have been camping at the Sololo Police Station, on the outskirts of Moyale town, since their houses were burned down. Moyale town has also been affected, with transport paralysed a week after some vehicles there were torched.

Abdi Wario, a Moyale trader, spoke of the hardships businesspeople are undergoing. "No vehicle has left Moyale for a week now. Some retail traders have nothing to sell. In my case, I have a lot of goods to sell but no buyers,” he said.

Livestock trade in the predominantly pastoral area has similarly been affected.

A health worker in Moyale, who preferred anonymity, said he had fled work due to threats. "Heath facilities have been closed. Health services has been disrupted and suspended in some areas because the nurses and clinical officers have also been affected by the conflicts and threatened," he said.

Who is fighting whom? 

The violence in Moyale is pitting the Borana and Gabra communities against one another.

A resident, Mbarak Haji, said that the Borana community has been targeted. “We are on self-defense. Our people have been attacked and our houses are being torched in a well-planned scheme to displace us,” he said, adding that deadly clashes have persisted in Marsabit for more than three years due to a failure to arrest leaders who openly plan attacks.

Moyale is located in Marsabit County.

An elder from the Gabra community, however, blamed their rivals, saying that the clashes are aimed at paralysing county development activities.

Why are they fighting?

The Borana and Gabra communities have perennially clashed over access to resources such water and pasture, as well as raiding each other’s livestock.

Indeed, cattle raids have been attributed to some of the recent attacks, according to KRCS. On 24 November, for example, a cattle raid was recorded in the Qate area, home to the Borana, leading to a fire-fight between the two communities. One person died.

In the recent past, conflict has intensified amid the process of devolution, which has brought government resources down to previously neglected regions, making land boundaries and political positions increasingly contested.

In Moyale, security officials and residents attribute some of the violence to the local county government’s allegedly skewed process of making appointments and awarding contracts. On 9 December, the Marsabit County Commissioner, Isaiah Nakoru, accused politicians of fuelling the conflicts, which have left more than 100 dead since January.

According to Balesa Habule, a civil rights activist, the spike in conflicts in Marsabit presents a new pattern of violent clashes in under-developed northern Kenya , which has suffered decades of cattle rustling and clashes over pasture and water.

"A devolved system of governance is what the region has been yearning for… The constitution acknowledges that this region has been neglected for long [and has] granted us equalization funds and resources. We either seize the opportunity or lose it,” said Habule.

The discovery of natural resources such as oil has further upped the stakes in northern Kenya, where mega infrastructure development projects are underway.

Are there any external actors?

On 9 December, local Borana leaders, led by Ali Rosa, the Moyale Member of Parliament, accused Kenyan and Ethiopian security forces of stoking the conflict to punish the community over their alleged support to the Oromo Liberation Front, an Ethiopian rebel group.

Commissioner Nakoru dismissed the reports, but he confirmed that Kenyan forces are liaising with Ethiopia to flush out militants.

Often, there are concerns that Gabra and Borana militias from Ethiopia may cross the border into Kenya to reinforce their kinsmen, escalating conflict.

What has been the response, both security and humanitarian?
Hundreds of Kenya Defence Forces soldiers, as well as regular police, have been deployed to Moyale and to other northern areas that have recently experienced conflict, such as the Samburu, Turkana and West Pokot counties, following recent parliamentary approval.

In Marsabit County, so far, some 52 people suspected of involvement in acts such as fighting, burning houses and barricading roads have been arrested, according to Commissioner Nakoru.

On 4 December, KRCS provided first-aid services for the injured following an attack on a lorry in the area of Holale, which left the driver and three people with limb injuries. KRCS has been evacuating the injured to various hospitals for treatment. As of 9 December, KRCS had helped to transfer at least 27 people to various hospitals within Moyale.

Tension remains high in Moyale, with suspicion rife, according to KRCS’s Omolo. KRCS has initiated a reconciliation and peace process with the leaders of the warring communities.

Non-food items have been distributed to some of the affected households in the Sololo and Turbi areas. KRCS is also conducting an assessment to establish an accurate number of those displaced to help resettle them.

na/aw/rz 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

In Kenya, information strengthens pastoralists' resilience

ISIOLO, 6 March 2013 (IRIN) - 
Inadequate access to information, such as weather forecasts, has hampered Kenyan pastoralists' ability to respond and adapt to climate change, experts say.

"Lack of adequate information and focus on emergency responses has left communities exposed to the effects of climate change. More focus must now go towards ensuring that the communities have the ability to withstand the effects of climate change. Building resilience is the way to go," Victor Orindi, climate change advisor in the Ministry of State for the Development of Northern Kenya and Other Arid Lands, told IRIN.

Kenya’s pastoralists face recurrent devastation from droughts, livestock deaths, loss of livelihood and conflict over resources.

Weather forecasts

A climate change adaptation project has been launched in Garbatulla, in the eastern county of Isiolo, which is inhabited mainly by pastoralist communities.

The project, funded through the Climate Adaptation Fund and developed by the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) and the Kenya Meteorological Department, will establish a radio station to broadcast weather forecasts in local languages.

"Pastoralists are the most disadvantaged group in Kenya. A majority are illiterate, can't read newspapers and don't understand languages used by all the radio and TV stations… [which] are the same facilities that are used to inform Kenyans about climate change," Mumina Bonaya, community mobilization manager for the NGO Resource Advocacy Programme, told IRIN.

The radio station, known as Badada FM, is expected to reach almost a million people from the Borana, Gabra, Samburu, Somali, Turkana and Rendile communities in northern Kenya. The radio station will focus on giving updates on looming droughts and floods, as well as information on climate change.

"Pastoralists are the most disadvantaged group in Kenya. A majority are illiterate, can't read newspapers and don't understand languages used by all the radio and TV stations… [which] are the same facilities that are used to inform Kenyans about climate change."
The project will additionally build links between pastoralists and researchers, weather experts, policymakers, government officials and aid agencies. It will also map grazing fields and community watering points, and will empower pastoralist communities to better manage and utilize these resources.

"Our county’s climate change resilience project, the first of its kind in Kenya, will mobilize resources, researchers and modern technology. We have changed the approach, and linked the herder down at the wards [villages] with key institutions at national and international level s," Bonaya said.

Through what are known as ward committees, communities can identify initiatives they find promising and request that they be funded. Similar projects are being piloted in five wards in eastern and northern Kenya.

Empowering communities

Jo Abbot, the deputy head of the UK's Department for International Development (DFID) in Kenya, said climate change-related challenges can be managed through the adoption of technology and by keeping communities abreast of weather patterns. But relaying weather forecasts through print and electronic media and television has meant that this information does not reach people like pastoralists. And the information available is often imprecise.

"Our delivery system makes it difficult to reach the end-users. Those who get it demand details such as exact amount of rainfall, onset and cessation, and this cannot be achieved in the predictions," Ayub Shaka, head of the Kenya Meteorological Department, said.

But empowering communities through resilience and early warning programmes improves pastoralists' coping mechanisms, and could work better than funding emergency programmes, experts say.

"It's cheap to prevent [disasters] and empower communities with information... Researchers and donors will both benefit [since] famine, diseases, loss of livestock or source of income, and conflicts are very costly. They affect education, the health sector and development plans," Daoud Tari, head of the Resource Advocacy Programme project, told IRIN.

na/ko/rz
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Hundreds displaced by fresh clashes in Isiolo

ISIOLO, 15 February 2012 (IRIN) - 
Hundreds of people have been displaced and six killed in a fresh wave of ethnic clashes in the central Kenyan region of Isiolo where a spate of attacks and counter-attacks since late 2011 have left dozens dead.

In the first attack on 13 February in Gambella, near Isiolo town [but in neighbouring Meru County], three farmers were killed on their farms “as they harvested tomatoes”; three more were killed on [14 February] at Kampi ya juu, Isaiah Nakoru, the provincial commissioner told IRIN.

One man was shot by the police after he attacked them as they were clearing a section of the Isiolo-Moyale highway blocked by people demonstrating against insecurity.

Several houses were burnt down in the attacks. "I lost everything, all clothes, cooking utensils,” said Aragai Lele, a widow and mother of seven.

Lele said she had been forced to have her children spend the night in three different houses as a precaution. “It was good to separate them," she said.

"We have so far managed to find 15 houses burnt at Chechelesi and Kampi ya juu. More than 1,000 people mainly from the Turkana community have fled the two areas,” said an aid worker who preferred anonymity. Chechelesi and Kampi ya juu are close to Isiolo town.

The aid worker added that tens of subsistence farmers from the Meru and Borana communities had abandoned their farms in Gambella and moved to Isiolo town. Others have moved to Maua, in Meru County, further south. Assessments to ascertain the number of those affected are ongoing, he said.

Shops and banks in Isiolo, as well as more than 15 primary schools in Isiolo and neighbouring parts of Meru, are closed.

“Isiolo is a war zone, many people have been killed and children orphaned. We have witnessed an increase in the number of widows; hundreds of families have lost their homes and been displaced, with no effort made to resettle them,” said an official with the Nomadic Community Rehabilitation Programme, Ahmed Mohamed.

According to analysts, the violence in Isiolo is politically motivated and could continue until the next general elections scheduled for either December 2012 or March 2013.

Local residents interviewed said the latest clashes were intended to cause a rift between Meru and Turkana voters who have planned an alliance ahead of the elections. Several communities have been caught up in the fighting, but most of the past violence has been between the Borana and the Turkana.

In a press statement on 15 February, Kenya Christian church leaders appealed to Kenyans “to reject any efforts by politicians to incite them against one another and shame and reject any leaders who stoke tribal emotion.”

“Without a definite election date, Kenyans remain anxious and the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission cannot sufficiently plan for the polls,” the church leaders said.

na/aw/cb 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Clashes highlight dangers of devolution

ISIOLO, 3 February 2012 (IRIN) - 
Politically motivated violence in the northern Kenyan town of Moyale, which has left dozens dead and tens of thousands displaced in recent weeks, shows little sign of abating and there are fears that the clashes could continue until elections are held for new local government positions.

The main two pastoralist communities involved, the Borana and the Gabra, have a long history of sometimes violent competition over resources.

But by many accounts, an unintended consequence of Kenya’s new devolutionary constitution has raised the stakes considerably. The prospect of real political and budgetary power - concentrated since independence in distant Nairobi - rather than water, pasture and cattle-raid vendettas, now drives the violence.

“Every conflict in 2012 will have political and ethnic implications and can therefore not be treated as normal criminal activity,” Mzalendo Kibunjia, chairman of the National Cohesion and Commission (NCIC), said in a recent statement.

The NCIC is a government entity set up in 2008 to eliminate ethnic discrimination and promote inter-communal reconciliation.

“The conflicts in northern Kenya must be treated as electoral related and not be dismissed as conflict over water, pasture and cattle rustling. The NCIC has established that the ongoing violent conflicts [in Moyale and Isiolo] are politically motivated in anticipation of the 2012 elections,” Kibunjia said.

However, presidential, legislative and local elections might not be held until early 2013 according to a recent High Court ruling.

The Kenya Red Cross added:“The trigger of the current conflict is allegedly competition over positions in the county government structures as designated in the new Kenyan constitution and land-related issues.”

Incitement 

The spate of sporadic clashes is thought to have been sparked by a single killing in early November just across the border with Ethiopia.

Since then, political leaders from each community have allegedly incited violence against the other, regardless of whether those members are combatants.

“Different communities used to share mixed schools, mixed waterholes, mixed shopping centres, mixed everything. Now they can’t be on the same street together,” said one aid worker, who recently visited the town.

Several political leaders, including a former member of parliament, have been arrested on suspicion of fuelling the increasingly generalized conflict.

“Here, a politician can kill his opponents, it happens every [election] year, but not a single politician or trader known to have planned and killed people has ever been convicted,” Aba Dika, an elder in Moyale, told IRIN.

However, Eastern Province Police Commander Marcus Ochola told IRIN such impunity was on the way out.

“I am confident our officers, who are still collecting additional evidence, will support strong cases against those responsible for these skirmishes,” he said.

Another police official said detectives were investigating reports that some suspects had used social media to incite violence and congratulate kinsmen when prominent members of rival communities had been killed.

Aid workers who visited Moyale said hundreds of houses had been burnt and that crops, livestock and property had been destroyed. There have also been reports of shortages and increasing food prices due to the interruption of transport and the closure or destruction of shops.

Thousands of people – insecurity has prevented an accurate assessment - have been displaced from their homes, with many fleeing into southern Ethiopia. The Red Cross estimates that 9,500 families – some 57,000 people – have fled, 60 people have been killed and more than 1,000 houses burnt.

The worst-affected areas include the settlements of Heilu, Kinisa, Buthye, Bori, Mansile, Illadu, Manyatta and Odda.

The UN’s World Food Programme suspended distributions to around 2,200 people in Heilu and Odda after 15 tonnes of food were looted from stores there in late January.


Photo: OCHA Eastern Africa
A map showing areas affected by conflict in Moyale
Traumatized 

“The extent of displacement now and the indiscriminate targeting of the violence – women, children and older persons, any member of the [rival] community has been killed – have left people really traumatized,” said one humanitarian official, who asked not to be named.

“The fear is that between now and elections [we] will see displacement and returns, displacement and returns, with nothing really in balance. There won’t be much room for manoeuvre until some sort of political solution is agreed upon. That seems very far away right now, from what we have seen,” he added.

“It’s not easy to arrange peace meetings when the parties are so mistrustful and fearful of the other’s intentions. Willingness and commitment are not there at the moment, it seems. Willingness to cease hostilities has been very low. It’s quite tragic,” said the aid worker.

Education blow

Education has been badly affected in Moyale, with 18 of the area’s 31 schools yet to reopen after the Christmas break and many school-age children among the displaced, either in Ethiopia or in makeshift camps.

Livestock trader Abduba Wario said his income had dried up because the town’s livestock market was closed and he had been unable to send his two daughters to school in the central Kenyan town of Meru.

"It's risky, no trucks are available. I appeal to the government and NGOs to provide all school-children with transport and police escorts for learning in other parts of the country," he said.

The state of education facilities serves as an important indicator of the wider security climate, according to the aid worker.

“Children returning to school is the first step in terms of reconciliation, a return to normality. If it is safe for children to go to school it is also safe for health workers and others to return to their posts,” he said.

Amid reports that leaders of warring communities have mobilized across the porous border, Kenyan security forces are working with those from Ethiopia.

"We are liaising with our counterparts in Ethiopia to trace the fighters who fled when Kenyan security officers were deployed to quell the fight,” said a security official, who asked not to be named.

na-aw-am/mw 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Violence in Isiolo is expected to escalate

NAIROBI, 25 November 2011 (IRIN) - 
Pre-election politics and planned development schemes have fuelled an upsurge in inter-communal killings and forced displacement in Kenya’s northern Isiolo area, which if left unaddressed, is likely to escalate, say analysts and civil society workers.

Several communities have been caught up in the unrest but the main protagonists are the Borana and Turkana ethnic groups. Recent events indicate the standard interpretation of the conflict being limited to tit-for-tat cattle rustling and drought-related resource conflict is superficial and outdated.

Isiolo features prominently in a major national development plan known as Vision 2030, whereby the town is set to be elevated to a “resort city”, complete with up-market hotels and a new airport to boost its tourism potential, rooted in nearby game-parks.

A road linking Isiolo to Moyale, which lies on the Ethiopian border, is being built while oil and gas exploration is under way in the wider Isiolo region.

“Organized” attacks

Since mid-October, seemingly organized attacks have claimed about 20 lives, including those of seven children, and led to the displacement of some 2,900 households, according to humanitarian sources and local officials.

Livestock was not stolen in most of these incidents but dozens of dwellings were set ablaze. Most of the targeted settlements are inhabited by Turkana people. Continuing insecurity has greatly hampered humanitarian response to the displaced, who in many cases fled so quickly they had no time to take any possessions, and whose plight is worsened by the onset of heavy rains.

There is also a “desperate need” for shelter and non-food items such as mosquito nets, kitchen kits, jerry cans, soap, blankets and sleeping mats, according to the findings of a mission to Isiolo conducted by UNICEF, adding that the lack of latrines in displacement sites had resulted in sickness and worries about more cases.

“The Isiolo conflict is political: this is driven by the 2012 election,” said a researcher, who asked not to be named because of the tension. “Certain communities are being incited by sitting politicians who are eyeing the new county positions like governorship, senatorship and parliamentary seats.”

Kenya’s new constitution created 47 new counties to help devolve political and economic power.

“These conflicts are to inflict fear and displace the so-called minority communities in Isiolo,” he said.

“In the absence of appropriate security measures and law-enforcement interventions aimed at preventing future clashes and inter-ethnic violence, there is a real risk that the situation could deteriorate significantly in the lead-up to the 2012 elections,” UNICEF said in its mission report.

Leaders of various communities – Somali, Samburu, Gabra and Rendille as well as Turkana and Borana – told IRIN they blamed the escalation of violence on the failure of local authorities to address the root causes of the unrest.

"The police and army have not and will never resolve disputes among the locals,” said Joseph Kalapata of the Forum for the Protection of Pastoralist Development.

“Our people should be informed that they all lose conflicts. They also need to understand that he current constitution guarantees equal sharing of resources," he added.

Some leaders also pointed to the failure of a disarmament operation in 2010 to rid some pastoralist communities of all of their weapons. There are plans to renew the exercise in December.

Economic conflict

The Borana are the largest and politically dominant ethnic group in Isiolo. Drought in 2011 led to an influx of large numbers of pastoralists from various groups. Isiolo’s economic growth has also served as a magnet.

In the 2007 general election, the local parliamentary seat was won by a Borana, with a Turkana coming a close second.

“These conflicts are being used by the Borana to suppress their future political and economic competitors like the Turkana and Somalis,” said the researcher.

The conflict is about “political numbers, not resources, because civilians, including women and children are being killed and nothing stolen”, he said.

“How do you kill a small child and shoot a pregnant woman? Why should you kill people at two in the morning, shoot people while they are still sleeping? These are the questions we need to ask ourselves,” said an Isiolo-based civil society worker.


Displaced 

“As we are talking, many Turkana have run away from their homes, it is really a pity,” said the civil society worker. “The Turkana also happen to be in quite a number of places where these developments will be.”

“Let the truth be told, the Turkana are holding large swathes of land to the detriment of other communities,” a senior member of Isiolo county council was reported as telling a recent meeting convened to discuss deteriorating security.

The Turkana are mainly located in the outskirts of Isiolo town.

“There are five major communities in Isiolo which are all fighting for recognition. All of them think that they have a stake, leading to misunderstandings and the formation of alliances that have led to the loss of lives,” the civil society worker said.

“We want people to go back to normality with no more deaths. This kind of organized intimidation has to stop,” he said.

According to local sources who spoke to IRIN, a lack of clear land tenure policy has helped fuel conflict in the area as tracts earmarked for development are taken over, or “grabbed”, by people keen to cash in on Vision 2030.

Another source of tension is private game parks, known as “conservancies”, tourist destinations also designed to reduce poaching and promote community development. The Borana and Somali communities feel excluded from the economic benefits they deliver as well as their rich pastureland.

According to a priest in Isiolo, Jeremia Ndungu: “The great concern is how to broker peace among the communities who are unequal in matters of resources.”

Mama Kapua, a Turkana mother-of-12, fled her home in the Isiolo suburb of Kambi Garba after it was attacked on 22 October. Her husband, who stayed behind with one of their sons, died when the house was set on fire. The son escaped with burns.

“They [the attackers] are bringing in people from outside Isiolo who cannot speak Kiswahili. They are here to fight,” she told IRIN.

“My husband had nothing valuable worth being killed for. My son was preparing for exams,” she said, explaining that she managed to escape with the help of an ethnic Somali neighbour who lent her a niqab as a disguise.

aw/na/am/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

ETHIOPIA-KENYA: Who rules the range?

For pastoral communities, the rangeland is perceived as a single, communally-owned economic resource (file photo)
LONDON, 24 October 2011 (IRIN) - The border land between Kenya and Ethiopia is a vast, open plain under a big sky. Hard red earth shows through the thin grass of the sun-baked landscape, an expanse of thorny scrub, flat-topped thorn-trees and tall red anthills. There are no fences or other visible boundaries, and few people, just occasional groups of cattle or goats with their herders. To the untutored eye it can look like empty land, where wandering nomads graze their animals at random.

But there is nothing random about it. This unpromising landscape can provide a good living for livestock if it is carefully managed, and the herds are kept on the move across the seasons so they make the optimum use of each area of pasture and each water source. Over the years, the herders have built up a great body of expertise about how best to manage the area's resources.

And the land is also definitely not "empty" in the sense that it belongs to no one - the people of the area are quite clear about whose land is whose, in terms not of individuals, but of different communities.

Sara Pavanello, who has just completed a three-year study of how natural resources are managed in the area, says: "The pastoralists I spoke to very often used collective terms, saying for example, 'Our resources, we decide, we manage…' For pastoral communities, the rangeland as a whole is perceived as one single economic resource that’s communally owned, even if this tract of rangeland has been divided by the international border. At the same time different ethnic groups own, or exercise control over specific territory and the natural resources found within it."

This does not mean that they exclude everyone else. They understand that other groups need access to the pasture and water sources at certain seasons. That kind of temporary access is traditionally negotiated between the elders of the different communities. Elders told Pavanello: "Today they need us; tomorrow we will need them." She describes this kind of sharing as being seen as an "insurance policy for the future".

Land ownership conundrum 

It is a model that makes perfect sense to the Borana, Gabra and Garri, the three ethnic groups which live along and across the border, but one that the conventional authorities struggle with, both in Ethiopia and Kenya. Land in Kenya is, for the most part, in private ownership. In Ethiopia all land belongs to the people, represented by the state. Neither system is designed to cope with private land, communally owned.

In Ethiopia, farmers are granted land to cultivate, and have security of possession under the constitution. Pavanello and her co-author, Simon Levine, say pastoralists’ rights are much weaker. The constitution gives them the right to use free land for grazing but, they write "the operative word here is free; the moment the state chooses to claim any grazing land, and declare it no longer 'free' the pastoralists lose any right to graze."

The authorities also tend to want to introduce resource management schemes to make the rangelands more productive, failing to see and understand the subtle and flexible management systems already in place involving elders and community institutions.

In their research Pavanello and Levine found cases where local administrators were enforcing ideas of ownership, citizenship and nationality which cut across the communities’ traditional right to manage their lands. In Kenya they say district officials reportedly cited the principle of freedom of movement for Kenyan citizens under the constitution in order to allow Somali clans into the rangelands of Borana clans around Moyale, despite the elders’ protests that it would exhaust the grazing.


On the other side of the border Ethiopia’s policy of "ethnic federalism" puts the Garri in Somali Region and the Borana in Orommiya, and has led, say Pavanello and Levine, to administrators pressing pastoralist communities to adopt a more exclusionary approach to natural resources, failing, they say, “to recognize the fact that granting secondary users rights of access is in customary law a legal obligation, which reinforces, rather than undermines the primary holders' claims of ownership rights and sovereignty over their territory”.

Cross-border mixed committees

The challenge is clearly how to harmonize traditional and formal regulation in a way which allows the flexibility and freedom of movement on which the productivity of the rangelands depends. Here the paper focuses on the growth of cross-border mixed committees on which both local government officials and community elders are represented, along with other groups such as young people and women. Set up mostly to deal with cattle raiding, the committees have also had some success in the joint management of pasture and water resources in the border areas, with communities from both sides sharing the resources and jointly negotiating access for other groups.

The idea of these mixed committees generated a lot of interest at the launch of the report earlier this month at London’s Overseas Development Institute. Jeremy Swift, a pastoralist development specialist with a lifetime of experience in the field, said bringing formal and customary regulation together was necessary, but likely to be difficult. "Formal rules have to be uniform throughout the country; customary rules are place and time specific. This is only likely to work if there is a real delegation of authority, which governments are not usually happy about and not likely to do willingly."

John Morton of the University of Greenwich cautioned against any attempt to bypass formal government structures. "Clearly this border is very fluid, but the states are still real, and you have to respect state authority and boundaries. You don’t do people any favours by over-stressing cross-border action which may label pastoralists as having divided loyalties."

The co-author of the report, Simon Levine, said they also had some reservations about the hybrid committees. "For example, in a case where it is the committee which decides who can use a water point, you are in effect negating the idea that the people who used to call themselves the owners of that land now have the right to exclude anyone. Now that may be a good thing or it may be a bad thing, but it does seem to me that it is not necessarily always going to be a good thing, especially where you know that the power relations within the committee may not always be equal… I would have thought the idea of hybrid committees is possibly and hopefully a way forward, but one that needs an awful lot more caution than I heard expressed today."

eb/cb
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Inter-ethnic clashes result in deaths, school closures

Inter-ethnic fighting has left 14 people dead in Isiolo district (file photo)
ISIOLO, 21 October 2011 (IRIN) - 
A flare-up in inter-ethnic fighting between communities in the northern Kenyan region of Isiolo over pasture and water has left at least 14 people dead and affected learning as schools closed amid rising insecurity, say officials.

Borana and Turkana pastoralists clashed several times between 13 and 18 October, according to UN reports.

On 14 October, for example, seven people were shot dead in Tractor village, Ngaremara Division, Isiolo. According to local media reports, they included two 12-year-old children, who were dragged out of their huts and shot as their parents watched.

According to Dominic Opee, the Isiolo District Education Officer, the insecurity in Ngaremara has led to the closure of at least six schools. “We are concerned that innocent children are losing a very important opportunity to access education,” said Opee.

An estimated 3,000 children in the Ngaremara and Central divisions are affected – even as pupils countrywide prepare for the main primary school leaving exams in November.

“We regret these unfortunate incidents. [Some] parents and two pupils have been killed,” said Dade Boru, the Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT) Isiolo Branch Executive Secretary, adding that some of the teachers had received death threats too.

“Teachers must not be considered as enemies even if they belong to a community which is perceived as a rival group; this perception adversely affects equitable distribution of teachers, performance and heightens animosity amongst the warring communities and wrecks the minds of our children,” said Boru.

KNUT has advised affected teachers to remain at home and requested transfers for those who have been threatened.

The teachers in Isiolo are predominantly from the Borana, Somali and Meru communities.

Ekwam Terru, a local Turkana leader, said: “[The] Turkana have suffered a series of raids. We have been killed, thousands of our livestock stolen, we no longer have enough land for grazing our few animals.

“This is not normal banditry or cattle rustling, it’s a scheme to uproot us from our grazing land,” said Terru.

Josephine Ekiru, also a Turkana, said women were not able to access Isiolo Town for medical care and to buy food. “Some families have slept hungry some days. They have been unable to get into town to buy food; most of them sell charcoal to buy food [but] it’s risky and some have been attacked,” she said.

An Isiolo leader, Joseph Samal, said families were abandoning the good grazing areas in Gottu, Attan and Daaba to congregate in areas around Ngaremara, which lacks adequate pasture.

The insecurity has also affected the trade in livestock and related products from areas farther north, such as Marsabit and Moyale, to Nairobi after a truck driver was killed in a revenge attack.

A camel milk vendor, Marian Maalim, told IRIN that the movement of camel herds away from Isiolo Town, due to a fear of raids, had affected business. Maalim sells the milk to customers in Nairobi’s Eastleigh Estate.

In response, the government has deployed hundreds of security officers to the area and was pursuing the attackers, said the Upper Eastern Regional commissioner Isaiah Nakoru.

“We have police officers in all the affected villages and grazing areas; no attack has occurred since Monday [17 October],” he said.

“Tension remains high in Isiolo due to a general fear of retaliatory attacks,” says the UN, adding that the activities of some UN agencies operating in the region had been affected due to restrictions on movement.

na/aw/mw
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: What's new on the drought



Photo: Ann Weru/IRIN
Scarce resources...
ISIOLO/MARSABIT, 13 September 2011 (IRIN) 
- Pastoralists in the drought-hit northern and eastern part of Kenya are often caught up in conflict over resources as well as movements of livestock in search of water and pasture.

Here IRIN offers the latest information from the region and testimony from pastoralists to illustrate the challenges they cope with daily:

- Worsening drought has led to increased conflict and cattle rustling in the past three months in parts of Isiolo, Samburu, Meru west and Laikipia districts as many pastoralists move to these areas in search of pasture, water and food, say local officials. Widespread livestock migration is affecting at least 80 percent of herds.

- On 8 September, seven people, among them herders and police reservists, were killed in the Kom area along the Isiolo-Samburu border in the northwest during a livestock raid. The herders had migrated to Kom - where there is still pasture - from their traditional drought-affected grazing lands.

- In Isiolo district, more than 20 people have been killed in battles over resources in the past two months, according to local sources.

- Dozens of farming households have been displaced in Mwingi and Kitui in eastern Kenya after an influx of livestock from neighbouring pastoral districts after loss of livelihood productivities, according to the Famine Early Warning Systems Network (FEWS NET).

- Stephen Momanyi, the District Commissioner of Tseikuru, north of Mwingi region, told IRIN: "When the herders came, they started grazing their livestock on the local farms which had withering crops. Some of the local farmers in return started stealing the herders' livestock and in retaliation the herders burned some houses. But we moved to quickly contain the situation." He added that at least one person was killed in the conflict, which temporarily displaced about 500 people.

- The Inter-Governmental Authority on Development (IGAD) Climate Predication and Applications Centre projects an increased likelihood of above- to near-normal rainfall in the October-December short rains season over the coastal and northeastern Kenya areas.

Conflict resolution

- Joseph Kalapata, a peace and conflict resolution campaigner, says greater effort should be made to stop the rise in conflicts over resources. "Although we have enough grazing land and water, access and sharing of the resources is being hampered by insecurity. Our animals must not die because a certain community wants to have access and control [over] resources alone by use of force."

- According to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) in Kenya, at least 112 people died in such resource-based conflict between January and May, against 68 deaths over the same period in 2010. More killings, including those associated with cross-border livestock raids, have been recorded mainly in the northwestern Turkana region.


Photo: Jaspreet Kindra/IRIN
... require better management
- Various peace initiativesare under way, says Daud Tamasot, a programme officer with Community Initiative Facilitation and Assistance (CIFA), an NGO working with pastoralist communities. CIFA is using sports activities and local elders to help spread the message of peace in the upper eastern districts of Chalbi and Marsabit.

- Gari Koro, a 70-year-old man from the Rendille community, said ongoing peace initiatives would enable free movement in search of pasture. "Even though [some of] the animals have died because of the drought, people still have some left and they have to look for pasture and water for them," he said. "Even the people need water but thewater holes are drying up and few are remaining."

- Better resource management is key in minimizing conflict, officials say. "It is important that communities' capacities are built [up] to be able to manage these resources in a communal manner and prepare communities for events like drought and dwindling resources and how to act in such situations," said Umuro Roba Godana, executive director of the Pastoralist Integrated Support Programme.

Disaster risk reduction

- A consortium of aid agencies and community development initiative groups has initiated disaster risk reduction campaigns in northern Kenya in a bid to prevent and manage the impact of drought, hunger, climate change and diseases on local populations. The Partners for Resilience project launched in August in Isiolo aims to sensitize pastoralist communities to the main factors responsible for the frequent calamities in the region.

- Aid workers say increased vulnerability and exposure to recurrent and extreme consequences of disasters result from poor interventions that focus on emergency responses rather than prevention and management preparedness. The Kenya Red Cross Society, the lead agency implementing the resilience project, says the new approach is less costly and better suited to eliminating frequent demands for emergency interventions.

- Abdi Malik Roba, who is leading the four-year resilience project, says activeinvolvement of the communities is a key factor in implementation and success of the initiative. "The identified areas, project sites, are most appropriate, [and] host different communities - Samburu, Borana, Somali, Rendille and Turkana - all from three provinces; it's an expansive area, favourable for grazing, with different sources of water, frequently hit by conflicts and a retreat for families who have lost animals to drought and cattle rustling."

- According to Paul Goldsmith, a researcher on pastoralism, communities need information communication technology (ICT) assistance to expand their sources of livelihoods. "ICT can help hundreds of school graduates and middle-level workers attain further studies through online courses and degrees. In this remote region there is no single college offering even a diploma."

ko-aw-na/js/mw 

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More

 
Powered by Blogger