Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Briefing: Escalating clashes in northern Kenya

Photo: Kenya Red Cross 
Damaged houses in Moyale in the aftermath of inter-ethnic conflict (file photo)
MOYALE, 11 December 2013 (IRIN) - 
A fresh outbreak of violence between communities in northern Kenya’s Moyale area – in Marsabit County - has displaced tens of thousands and led the government to take the almost unprecedented step of deploying its troops domestically in an effort to quell the unrest.

The violence, which has broken out intermittently since late 2011, has paralysed business and transport activities.

The attacks have often been abrupt in nature, targeting people at work or who are travelling, according to a 9 December Kenya Red Cross Society (KRCS)update .

There have been incidents of roads being barricaded, as well. On 28 November, transport between Moyale and Nairobi was cut off after the road was blocked at the Turbi area for over 10 hours, notes KRCS.

What is the current humanitarian situation?

As of 11 December, at least 72,000 people in Moyale have been uprooted from their homes,  according to KRCS, which notes that about a third of the displaced families have crossed the border into Ethiopia, after violence left at least 30 people dead in the previous week.

"More than 10 settlements have been completely deserted. We found no single soul in all the areas hard-hit by the clashes. All families have left and fled," Tom Omolo, KRCS’s regional disaster coordinator, told IRIN.  Some of the abandoned areas include the villages of Arosa, Butiye, Funanyata, Kote, Oda and Sololo.

Wario Lakicha, whose family is among those that have fled into Ethiopia, said: "We are suffering. Nobody is helping us. In some cases, more than 30 people are sharing one house; a large number are being hosted by relatives."

Also newly in Ethiopia, Wario Golicha, who fled the village of Butiye, told IRIN that his family is living in a flimsy structure made of polythene. For a toilet, the family is using the open fields. "We have no water, no food, no blankets, mosquito nets or bed, and sleep in darkness. My children have no clothes - they left them all as we fled," he said.

We have no water, no food, no blankets, mosquito nets or bed, and sleep in darkness. My children have no clothes - they left them all as we fled 
Several families have been camping at the Sololo Police Station, on the outskirts of Moyale town, since their houses were burned down. Moyale town has also been affected, with transport paralysed a week after some vehicles there were torched.

Abdi Wario, a Moyale trader, spoke of the hardships businesspeople are undergoing. "No vehicle has left Moyale for a week now. Some retail traders have nothing to sell. In my case, I have a lot of goods to sell but no buyers,” he said.

Livestock trade in the predominantly pastoral area has similarly been affected.

A health worker in Moyale, who preferred anonymity, said he had fled work due to threats. "Heath facilities have been closed. Health services has been disrupted and suspended in some areas because the nurses and clinical officers have also been affected by the conflicts and threatened," he said.

Who is fighting whom? 

The violence in Moyale is pitting the Borana and Gabra communities against one another.

A resident, Mbarak Haji, said that the Borana community has been targeted. “We are on self-defense. Our people have been attacked and our houses are being torched in a well-planned scheme to displace us,” he said, adding that deadly clashes have persisted in Marsabit for more than three years due to a failure to arrest leaders who openly plan attacks.

Moyale is located in Marsabit County.

An elder from the Gabra community, however, blamed their rivals, saying that the clashes are aimed at paralysing county development activities.

Why are they fighting?

The Borana and Gabra communities have perennially clashed over access to resources such water and pasture, as well as raiding each other’s livestock.

Indeed, cattle raids have been attributed to some of the recent attacks, according to KRCS. On 24 November, for example, a cattle raid was recorded in the Qate area, home to the Borana, leading to a fire-fight between the two communities. One person died.

In the recent past, conflict has intensified amid the process of devolution, which has brought government resources down to previously neglected regions, making land boundaries and political positions increasingly contested.

In Moyale, security officials and residents attribute some of the violence to the local county government’s allegedly skewed process of making appointments and awarding contracts. On 9 December, the Marsabit County Commissioner, Isaiah Nakoru, accused politicians of fuelling the conflicts, which have left more than 100 dead since January.

According to Balesa Habule, a civil rights activist, the spike in conflicts in Marsabit presents a new pattern of violent clashes in under-developed northern Kenya , which has suffered decades of cattle rustling and clashes over pasture and water.

"A devolved system of governance is what the region has been yearning for… The constitution acknowledges that this region has been neglected for long [and has] granted us equalization funds and resources. We either seize the opportunity or lose it,” said Habule.

The discovery of natural resources such as oil has further upped the stakes in northern Kenya, where mega infrastructure development projects are underway.

Are there any external actors?

On 9 December, local Borana leaders, led by Ali Rosa, the Moyale Member of Parliament, accused Kenyan and Ethiopian security forces of stoking the conflict to punish the community over their alleged support to the Oromo Liberation Front, an Ethiopian rebel group.

Commissioner Nakoru dismissed the reports, but he confirmed that Kenyan forces are liaising with Ethiopia to flush out militants.

Often, there are concerns that Gabra and Borana militias from Ethiopia may cross the border into Kenya to reinforce their kinsmen, escalating conflict.

What has been the response, both security and humanitarian?
Hundreds of Kenya Defence Forces soldiers, as well as regular police, have been deployed to Moyale and to other northern areas that have recently experienced conflict, such as the Samburu, Turkana and West Pokot counties, following recent parliamentary approval.

In Marsabit County, so far, some 52 people suspected of involvement in acts such as fighting, burning houses and barricading roads have been arrested, according to Commissioner Nakoru.

On 4 December, KRCS provided first-aid services for the injured following an attack on a lorry in the area of Holale, which left the driver and three people with limb injuries. KRCS has been evacuating the injured to various hospitals for treatment. As of 9 December, KRCS had helped to transfer at least 27 people to various hospitals within Moyale.

Tension remains high in Moyale, with suspicion rife, according to KRCS’s Omolo. KRCS has initiated a reconciliation and peace process with the leaders of the warring communities.

Non-food items have been distributed to some of the affected households in the Sololo and Turbi areas. KRCS is also conducting an assessment to establish an accurate number of those displaced to help resettle them.

na/aw/rz 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Displacement follows clashes on Kenya-Ethiopia border

MOYALE, 6 September 2013 (IRIN) - 
Thousands of families remain displaced from the northern Kenya district of Moyale, close to the Ethiopian border, following the latest spate of clan violence, which has left at least two dozen dead since it broke out on 30 August.

Aid agencies say they have been unable to conduct a comprehensive assessment of humanitarian needs, essential for providing emergency assistance to populations in some of the district's more volatile areas.

Two days of inter-clan fighting among the Gabra, Burji and Borana communities saw houses torched, gunfire exchanged and business come to a standstill in the areas of Somare and Teti. The violence has since subsided, but tension remains high in the area.

Education officials say all 32 primary and secondary schools in Moyale remained closed on 2 September, as all both teachers and students remained displaced, too afraid of renewed violence to return home.

The violence is believed to be part of a series of revenge attacks that began when the Borana and Gabra clashed on 15 July, leaving one dead and three wounded.

Displaced

"More than 38,000 people from 6,381 households have been forced to leave their homes," said the Kenya Red Cross Society's (KRCS) Moyale coordinator, Stephen Bonaya, who noted that most of the displaced had crossed into Ethiopia, while others were staying with relatives in Moyale and the counties of Marsabit and Wajir.

He said scores of children, women and men were still separated from their families, while others were missing. "A team is helping families trace lost members and reunite them. At the moment, 60 families have been united," he added.

According to Bonaya, displaced families are in urgent need of food assistance, shelter, drugs, water, cooking utensils, clothing and mosquito nets, among other things.

Moyale's traders say the suspension of operations by transporters has led to a spike in food prices in the area.

"My lorry has been parked for a whole week now. I am afraid it could either be burnt or hijacked, and yet I am supposed to service a loan," said Golicha, a truck owner.

Ismail Adan, a livestock trader and a transporter, said the prices of hiring and ferrying livestock by lorries doubled as a result of the clashes. "It's not possible to make any profit from livestock trade. Animals at the market are too few and very expensive," he said.

Seeking a solution

Historically, the regions' communities - which straddle Kenya and Ethiopia - have fought over resources such as pasture and water for their livestock, butresearch by Tufts University and KRCS shows that the violence has recently become more deadly and communities and their leaders now seek to achieve control over these resources through the political system.

"The government is now in charge. Militia gangs from the warring communities have been flushed out [by the police and the army]," Marsabit County commissioner Isaiah Nakoru told IRIN. "Some have fled and crossed the border. We have arrested eight Ethiopians, two Kenya[ns]. The state is serious; nobody will escape punishment... Politicians responsible will not be spared."

He added that preliminary investigations had established that "foreign militia" armed with mortars and bombs had fuelled the fighting.

People affected by the conflict say the intermittent violence will continue unless the government addresses the root causes, involving the warring communities and their leaders.

"This is a political problem. Neither Kenya's entire military nor police can contain or end this problem. Arrest the politicians, involve all communities in the political process and share resources fairly," said one Moyale resident, who preferred anonymity.

Former national assembly speaker Francis Ole Kaparo said a peaceful solution to the conflict needed to be found. "These communities must stop this bloody way of resolving disputes and share them [resources] or lose all anticipated benefits," he told IRIN.

na/kr/rz 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

In Kenya, information strengthens pastoralists' resilience

ISIOLO, 6 March 2013 (IRIN) - 
Inadequate access to information, such as weather forecasts, has hampered Kenyan pastoralists' ability to respond and adapt to climate change, experts say.

"Lack of adequate information and focus on emergency responses has left communities exposed to the effects of climate change. More focus must now go towards ensuring that the communities have the ability to withstand the effects of climate change. Building resilience is the way to go," Victor Orindi, climate change advisor in the Ministry of State for the Development of Northern Kenya and Other Arid Lands, told IRIN.

Kenya’s pastoralists face recurrent devastation from droughts, livestock deaths, loss of livelihood and conflict over resources.

Weather forecasts

A climate change adaptation project has been launched in Garbatulla, in the eastern county of Isiolo, which is inhabited mainly by pastoralist communities.

The project, funded through the Climate Adaptation Fund and developed by the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) and the Kenya Meteorological Department, will establish a radio station to broadcast weather forecasts in local languages.

"Pastoralists are the most disadvantaged group in Kenya. A majority are illiterate, can't read newspapers and don't understand languages used by all the radio and TV stations… [which] are the same facilities that are used to inform Kenyans about climate change," Mumina Bonaya, community mobilization manager for the NGO Resource Advocacy Programme, told IRIN.

The radio station, known as Badada FM, is expected to reach almost a million people from the Borana, Gabra, Samburu, Somali, Turkana and Rendile communities in northern Kenya. The radio station will focus on giving updates on looming droughts and floods, as well as information on climate change.

"Pastoralists are the most disadvantaged group in Kenya. A majority are illiterate, can't read newspapers and don't understand languages used by all the radio and TV stations… [which] are the same facilities that are used to inform Kenyans about climate change."
The project will additionally build links between pastoralists and researchers, weather experts, policymakers, government officials and aid agencies. It will also map grazing fields and community watering points, and will empower pastoralist communities to better manage and utilize these resources.

"Our county’s climate change resilience project, the first of its kind in Kenya, will mobilize resources, researchers and modern technology. We have changed the approach, and linked the herder down at the wards [villages] with key institutions at national and international level s," Bonaya said.

Through what are known as ward committees, communities can identify initiatives they find promising and request that they be funded. Similar projects are being piloted in five wards in eastern and northern Kenya.

Empowering communities

Jo Abbot, the deputy head of the UK's Department for International Development (DFID) in Kenya, said climate change-related challenges can be managed through the adoption of technology and by keeping communities abreast of weather patterns. But relaying weather forecasts through print and electronic media and television has meant that this information does not reach people like pastoralists. And the information available is often imprecise.

"Our delivery system makes it difficult to reach the end-users. Those who get it demand details such as exact amount of rainfall, onset and cessation, and this cannot be achieved in the predictions," Ayub Shaka, head of the Kenya Meteorological Department, said.

But empowering communities through resilience and early warning programmes improves pastoralists' coping mechanisms, and could work better than funding emergency programmes, experts say.

"It's cheap to prevent [disasters] and empower communities with information... Researchers and donors will both benefit [since] famine, diseases, loss of livestock or source of income, and conflicts are very costly. They affect education, the health sector and development plans," Daoud Tari, head of the Resource Advocacy Programme project, told IRIN.

na/ko/rz
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Abdi Adan," Right now, I am a beggar with no home"

Photo: Noor Ali/IRIN
“I have attended the burials of more than 60 people in the past six months”

ISOLO, 2 April 2012 (IRIN) - 

Abdi Adan, an ethnic Somali living in Kenya’s central region of Isiolo, which has recently seen clashes between the Borana, Somali and Turkana communities and the displacement of thousands of people, tells IRIN about his experience of the violence. 

"I will always remember the past year’s events, the killing of family members, friends, neighbours and many residents of my village, Kampi Garba [2km from Isiolo town]. 

“These days, I spend most of the day mourning with relatives and families whose father, mother or son has been killed. 

“About 10 minutes ago, I attended the burial of a teacher who was killed yesterday [28 March] at Kilimani village [in Isiolo]; I helped to dig the grave. This is not the first, and I am afraid most likely not the last, burial I will attend. I have attended the burials of more than 60 people in the past six months. 

"I am afraid to attend more burials, it could be a close family member; anything is possible in Isiolo now. 

“I almost lost my [six] children, and the seven children of my late brother who was abducted by bandits last month [February] and killed, on the most painful day in my life - the day I lost all my camels and my house was burnt. 

“It's painful to lose - in less than five minutes - livestock and property that you have struggled to accumulate for more than 20 years. 

“I worked as a herder, moved to town, started operating as a livestock trader and broker and managed to build this house and bought the camels. But right now, I am a beggar with no home, no property and worst of all without clothes. 

“I live like a wild animal, worse than a bird which is sure [of] where to get its food and shelter. At the moment, I have moved my children and my late brother’s children to relatives’ and clan members’ houses in Bullapesa [Isiolo], which is safe. They stay in four different houses, while I stay in a friend’s kitchen with my wife; we have been separated by circumstances. I never imagined that I would lead this kind of life. 

“The skirmishes in Isiolo have affected my life, diminished my status. I am a beggar because my children rely on relatives and clan members to feed them. They get very little and are not comfortable. 

“My children have not attended school for the last three months; three of them have said they are no longer interested in going back to school. They are still shocked and not ready to go back to Kambi Garba. 

“More than 20 houses have been burnt [in] our village. Many people have fled to town; we all need assistance… shelter, tents and food. The few lucky people are selling their animals to rent houses in town, while many families have fled far away from Isiolo. 

“A truck [loaded] with 200 bags of rice for distribution to the displaced families was at Nomad Village, less than 200m away on [29 March] morning but we were unable to get the food because it’s impossible to move past Gaza Strip, the boundary between us and the Turkana ethnic group.” 

na/aw/cb 

[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Hundreds displaced by fresh clashes in Isiolo

ISIOLO, 15 February 2012 (IRIN) - 
Hundreds of people have been displaced and six killed in a fresh wave of ethnic clashes in the central Kenyan region of Isiolo where a spate of attacks and counter-attacks since late 2011 have left dozens dead.

In the first attack on 13 February in Gambella, near Isiolo town [but in neighbouring Meru County], three farmers were killed on their farms “as they harvested tomatoes”; three more were killed on [14 February] at Kampi ya juu, Isaiah Nakoru, the provincial commissioner told IRIN.

One man was shot by the police after he attacked them as they were clearing a section of the Isiolo-Moyale highway blocked by people demonstrating against insecurity.

Several houses were burnt down in the attacks. "I lost everything, all clothes, cooking utensils,” said Aragai Lele, a widow and mother of seven.

Lele said she had been forced to have her children spend the night in three different houses as a precaution. “It was good to separate them," she said.

"We have so far managed to find 15 houses burnt at Chechelesi and Kampi ya juu. More than 1,000 people mainly from the Turkana community have fled the two areas,” said an aid worker who preferred anonymity. Chechelesi and Kampi ya juu are close to Isiolo town.

The aid worker added that tens of subsistence farmers from the Meru and Borana communities had abandoned their farms in Gambella and moved to Isiolo town. Others have moved to Maua, in Meru County, further south. Assessments to ascertain the number of those affected are ongoing, he said.

Shops and banks in Isiolo, as well as more than 15 primary schools in Isiolo and neighbouring parts of Meru, are closed.

“Isiolo is a war zone, many people have been killed and children orphaned. We have witnessed an increase in the number of widows; hundreds of families have lost their homes and been displaced, with no effort made to resettle them,” said an official with the Nomadic Community Rehabilitation Programme, Ahmed Mohamed.

According to analysts, the violence in Isiolo is politically motivated and could continue until the next general elections scheduled for either December 2012 or March 2013.

Local residents interviewed said the latest clashes were intended to cause a rift between Meru and Turkana voters who have planned an alliance ahead of the elections. Several communities have been caught up in the fighting, but most of the past violence has been between the Borana and the Turkana.

In a press statement on 15 February, Kenya Christian church leaders appealed to Kenyans “to reject any efforts by politicians to incite them against one another and shame and reject any leaders who stoke tribal emotion.”

“Without a definite election date, Kenyans remain anxious and the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission cannot sufficiently plan for the polls,” the church leaders said.

na/aw/cb 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Clashes highlight dangers of devolution

ISIOLO, 3 February 2012 (IRIN) - 
Politically motivated violence in the northern Kenyan town of Moyale, which has left dozens dead and tens of thousands displaced in recent weeks, shows little sign of abating and there are fears that the clashes could continue until elections are held for new local government positions.

The main two pastoralist communities involved, the Borana and the Gabra, have a long history of sometimes violent competition over resources.

But by many accounts, an unintended consequence of Kenya’s new devolutionary constitution has raised the stakes considerably. The prospect of real political and budgetary power - concentrated since independence in distant Nairobi - rather than water, pasture and cattle-raid vendettas, now drives the violence.

“Every conflict in 2012 will have political and ethnic implications and can therefore not be treated as normal criminal activity,” Mzalendo Kibunjia, chairman of the National Cohesion and Commission (NCIC), said in a recent statement.

The NCIC is a government entity set up in 2008 to eliminate ethnic discrimination and promote inter-communal reconciliation.

“The conflicts in northern Kenya must be treated as electoral related and not be dismissed as conflict over water, pasture and cattle rustling. The NCIC has established that the ongoing violent conflicts [in Moyale and Isiolo] are politically motivated in anticipation of the 2012 elections,” Kibunjia said.

However, presidential, legislative and local elections might not be held until early 2013 according to a recent High Court ruling.

The Kenya Red Cross added:“The trigger of the current conflict is allegedly competition over positions in the county government structures as designated in the new Kenyan constitution and land-related issues.”

Incitement 

The spate of sporadic clashes is thought to have been sparked by a single killing in early November just across the border with Ethiopia.

Since then, political leaders from each community have allegedly incited violence against the other, regardless of whether those members are combatants.

“Different communities used to share mixed schools, mixed waterholes, mixed shopping centres, mixed everything. Now they can’t be on the same street together,” said one aid worker, who recently visited the town.

Several political leaders, including a former member of parliament, have been arrested on suspicion of fuelling the increasingly generalized conflict.

“Here, a politician can kill his opponents, it happens every [election] year, but not a single politician or trader known to have planned and killed people has ever been convicted,” Aba Dika, an elder in Moyale, told IRIN.

However, Eastern Province Police Commander Marcus Ochola told IRIN such impunity was on the way out.

“I am confident our officers, who are still collecting additional evidence, will support strong cases against those responsible for these skirmishes,” he said.

Another police official said detectives were investigating reports that some suspects had used social media to incite violence and congratulate kinsmen when prominent members of rival communities had been killed.

Aid workers who visited Moyale said hundreds of houses had been burnt and that crops, livestock and property had been destroyed. There have also been reports of shortages and increasing food prices due to the interruption of transport and the closure or destruction of shops.

Thousands of people – insecurity has prevented an accurate assessment - have been displaced from their homes, with many fleeing into southern Ethiopia. The Red Cross estimates that 9,500 families – some 57,000 people – have fled, 60 people have been killed and more than 1,000 houses burnt.

The worst-affected areas include the settlements of Heilu, Kinisa, Buthye, Bori, Mansile, Illadu, Manyatta and Odda.

The UN’s World Food Programme suspended distributions to around 2,200 people in Heilu and Odda after 15 tonnes of food were looted from stores there in late January.


Photo: OCHA Eastern Africa
A map showing areas affected by conflict in Moyale
Traumatized 

“The extent of displacement now and the indiscriminate targeting of the violence – women, children and older persons, any member of the [rival] community has been killed – have left people really traumatized,” said one humanitarian official, who asked not to be named.

“The fear is that between now and elections [we] will see displacement and returns, displacement and returns, with nothing really in balance. There won’t be much room for manoeuvre until some sort of political solution is agreed upon. That seems very far away right now, from what we have seen,” he added.

“It’s not easy to arrange peace meetings when the parties are so mistrustful and fearful of the other’s intentions. Willingness and commitment are not there at the moment, it seems. Willingness to cease hostilities has been very low. It’s quite tragic,” said the aid worker.

Education blow

Education has been badly affected in Moyale, with 18 of the area’s 31 schools yet to reopen after the Christmas break and many school-age children among the displaced, either in Ethiopia or in makeshift camps.

Livestock trader Abduba Wario said his income had dried up because the town’s livestock market was closed and he had been unable to send his two daughters to school in the central Kenyan town of Meru.

"It's risky, no trucks are available. I appeal to the government and NGOs to provide all school-children with transport and police escorts for learning in other parts of the country," he said.

The state of education facilities serves as an important indicator of the wider security climate, according to the aid worker.

“Children returning to school is the first step in terms of reconciliation, a return to normality. If it is safe for children to go to school it is also safe for health workers and others to return to their posts,” he said.

Amid reports that leaders of warring communities have mobilized across the porous border, Kenyan security forces are working with those from Ethiopia.

"We are liaising with our counterparts in Ethiopia to trace the fighters who fled when Kenyan security officers were deployed to quell the fight,” said a security official, who asked not to be named.

na-aw-am/mw 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

KENYA: Thousands flee fatal clashes in Moyale

MOYALE, 5 January 2012 (IRIN) - 
At least six people have been killed in a fresh wave of fighting between two rival groups near the northern Kenya town of Moyale, prompting thousands to flee their homes, aid agencies and residents told IRIN.

The latest clashes between the Borana and Gabra communities, which follow weeks of unrest in December, began on 3 January and continued into the following day.

The fighting reportedly broke out after a disagreement between youths at a peace meeting degenerated first into an exchange of stones, then gunfire.

The Kenya Red Cross Society said six people had so far been confirmed dead, three of them children, and dozens of houses had been burnt. Three other people were reported to have sustained serious injuries.

Difficulties in accessing the affected villages of Odha, Kanisa, Masille, Iladu and Hellu led officials to believe the final toll could rise significantly,

Some 1,700 children from these villages have been unable to attend school because they fled with their families to Moyale town, according to one education official.

Reacting to complaints of government inaction, Regional Commissioner Issah Nakoru said: “Our people must be assured that the government has deployed more than 1,000 security officers in Moyale and Isiolo [about 500km to the southwest].”

Residents “have a role to play. Tell us those who among them are engaged in the fight and those who are inciting the communities to fight,” he said.

na/am/mw 
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More

 
Powered by Blogger